1967 - Kari Pederson Cynar *

1967 - Lynn Memoly Lerner **

1968 - Susan Martin

1969 - Karen Brunn

1970 - Joan Boracchio

1971 - Deborah Casley Pavlich

1972 - Loraine Barron

1973 - Barbara J. Lopez

1974 - Wanda Drew

1975 - Janice Avery Ould

1976 - Noreen Moss

1977 - Susan Christiansen **

1978 - Karen Notare

1979 - Kathleen Notare

1980 - Antoinette D'Addio

1981 - Claire Leach

1982 - Kim Osgood

1983 - Wendy Brown

1984 - Gina Biancardi

1985 - Alice Knisley*

1986 - Laureen Pesce

1987 - Eileen Green

1988 - Anna Marie Truncali

1989 - Gail Willadsen

1990 - Gracelyn Fernandez Santos

1991 - Jennifer Alaimo

1992 - Yolanda Zawisny

1993 - Stommy Holder

1994 - Kristina Ferraro

1995 - Jennifer Hicks

1996 - Samantha Stern

1997 - Sandra Ali

1998 - Deana Herrera*

1999 - Amy Reher

2000 - Jennifer Vernazza

2001 - Brenda Barreto

2002 - Ryan Kelly

2003 - Sarah Madej

2004 - Marissa Ann Terzano

2005 - Kimberley Ferdinando

2006 - Cassandra Ruiz

2007 - Elise Rooker

2008 - Melissa Robson

* Won Miss New York State Title

** Took Over Crown